Back to Blog

Good Intentions, Bad Outcomes: Common Errors in Nonprofit Financial Decision-Making

By Published Last updated
Good Intentions, Bad Outcomes: Common Errors in Nonprofit Financial Decision-Making

Is your nonprofit making financial decisions that look responsible but aren't? Learn six common errors and how to make context-driven choices instead.

The nonprofit world is full of well-intentioned people working with limited resources. Leaders must make tough decisions in an environment where success can be difficult to measure and the margin for error is thin. Often, they make these decisions based on sector-wide heuristics about what makes a healthy nonprofit. And those heuristics are often wrong, or at least incomplete.

In September’s webinar, Nicole Segura (Segura Strategy Group) shared her research into nearly 5,000 IRS filings and what they reveal about nonprofit financial health. We also discussed why so many well-intentioned financial decisions don't hold up once you dig into that data. Here, you’ll find six of the key takeaways from the session: Decision-making errors that show up time and time again in the nonprofit world.  

Six Decisions That Look Safe But Aren’t

1. Reserves Without a Purpose

Nonprofits are often told to build up their reserves. And while it is necessary to have a rainy day fund, it’s important to define what, exactly, your rainy day looks like and how much you’d realistically need to keep the lights on. 

You’ll want to strike a balance here. Save too little, and you’re vulnerable to even minor emergencies; save too much, and you’re squirreling away resources that could be put to better use elsewhere. 

To figure out what a healthy operating reserve looks like for your org, start by benchmarking yourself against organizations structured like yours — what Nicole Segura calls your financial archetype (covered in our last post).  Then, name your specific risks and build your target around those. 

2. Mistaking Reserves for Health

While having adequate reserves can be an indicator of resilience, it is not necessarily a sign of good financial health overall. An organization can hold months of cash on hand while its operations are in decline. And in fact, it’s often the case that deploying those funds to support and grow the organization would be the better move. 

So, which KPIs should you be looking at? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here; it largely depends on your organization’s size, structure, and funding mix. 

In short, you will need to build your tracking around your specific goals and the risks you face. A government-funded organization, for example, might prioritize tracking reimbursement timelines and administrative cost ratios, while a donation-funded organization might focus more on donor retention and month-over-month revenue trends. There’s no universal dashboard here; the metrics should align with how you operate.

3. Giving Up on Good Ideas Too Soon

Nonprofit leaders often underestimate how long it takes to bring a new initiative from the planning stage to full maturity. Say an organization wants to launch an earned-income venture, like a fee-for-service program. Six months in, revenue is still pretty thin, and leadership feels as though their efforts aren’t paying off. So they pull the plug.

But from what we’ve seen, these types of ventures often need between 9 and 18 months of data to produce a clear signal one way or the other, and it might take 3 to 5 years to fully develop into the vision leaders had at the outset. 

That’s why it’s important to set expectations early — define what progress should look like at regular intervals so you can tell whether you’re on the right trajectory. You will also need to have the right systems in place, both to manage this new branch of operations, and to track its performance against those milestones.

4. Diversification Without Direction

Diversifying revenue sounds like an unambiguous good. But there’s a difference between diversifying to build a stronger revenue engine and diversifying in a way that simply extracts resources. 

Say a grant opportunity comes up, a board member suggests a new idea, or another organization finds success with something similar. None of these are bad reasons to consider a new revenue stream. But without a clear throughline to the organization's strengths and mission, that new initiative can end up competing with the work it's supposed to support, rather than reinforcing it. 

A nonprofit known for its community workshops adding a modest fee-for-service version of that same work is building on what it already does well. The same nonprofit taking on an unrelated grant-funded program, just because the funding exists, is spreading itself thinner. Before chasing a new revenue stream, it's worth asking whether it’s building on what the organization is already doing, or diverting resources from it.

5. Buying Property Before You're Ready

A lot of nonprofits feel like owning property is the ultimate sign of stability. But, according to Nicole Segura’s research,  it doesn’t usually make sense for smaller organizations with an operating budget of less than $500,000. There are a few reasons for this.

For one, a down payment drains funds that might be better invested in the people and programs that really drive your impact. With smaller organizations, those types of investments tend to pay off far more in the long run than real estate. Buying property also means taking on all the costs of ownership: a plumbing issue or failing HVAC system can mean forking out thousands that a landlord would have otherwise covered. Finally, illiquid assets limit your flexibility. If your organization hits a downturn or growth phase, you’ll want to be able to pivot quickly rather than having to offload a property. 

At a certain point, it probably will make sense to start looking into ownership, but only once your organization has the revenue base and cash cushion to absorb it. 

6. Treating Peers as Rivals

It's easy to assume that organizations doing similar work are competing with you for the same limited pool of funding. But according to Nicole Segura's research, that assumption is usually wrong. When organizations identify the peer they see as their biggest rival, they often have a completely different funding structure. That mismatch matters. 

Two organizations working on the same issue (e.g., food insecurity), might be funded in entirely different ways: one through government contracts, the other through donations and in-kind support. Treating each other as competitors rather than potential collaborators, can mean missing real opportunities. These organizations could be applying for a grant together, pooling resources, or sharing an impact story that strengthens both of their positions with funders.

So before assuming another organization is working against you, it's worth researching how they’re funded. More often than not, there's more room to collaborate than compete. 

The Alternative: Decisions Based on Context

None of the above decisions are necessarily wrong; however, they must be made with context in mind. 

In the for-profit world, there are concrete metrics — profit and loss — to guide decisions. But for a nonprofit, things are more nuanced: your size, age, mission, and funding mix need to be taken into consideration at every turn. 

Before making a major financial decision, it's worth asking: how does this look for an organization like mine? Benchmarking against peers with a similar structure, rather than the sector as a whole, is one of the clearest ways to tell whether a decision actually fits your circumstances.

Building Financial Systems That Match Your Org’s Reality

Because context is everything, well-configured financial systems are critical — generic off-the-shelf accounting software won’t cut it. You’ll need dashboards that reflect the data that’s relevant to your organization specifically. 

The following questions are good starting points:

  • What is the one number that best reflects your mission?

  • Which activities are generating cash, and which are consuming it? 

  • How long could you operate if your largest funding source paused tomorrow?

  • Are you intentionally shifting your revenue mix, or is it just happening?

  • Which trends would signal a problem worth raising at the next board meeting?

With these types of questions in mind, you can build your tracking around how your organization actually operates. If you're not sure where to start, it might be worth getting outside help. At EBCFO Services, we take a systems-minded approach to nonprofit financial management so that leaders can make sound, data-driven decisions. If you need a hand, let’s talk. 

Takeaway

None of the decisions covered here come from bad intentions. Rather, they come from reasonable instincts applied without enough context. When you understand the nuances that drive your organization, you're in a much better position to make the right call, even when the "right" answer isn't obvious. And when you build your financial systems around those nuances, you can make sure your good intentions align with both your organization’s mission and its reality.